Summary: In order to win back her ex, CeCe follows him to a summer Bible camp.
Representation: One of the minor characters is lesbian.
Sexual Content: Probably easiest to just say...lots. It's central to the book's theme of sex positivity and consent. They talk about it a lot and there is one detailed sex scene.
Ace thoughts: I knew this book might be a bit of mine field going into it. I am both ace and deeply Christian. The book had excellent reviews, so I figured maybe the subjects were handled well and I'd give it a try. Honestly, I've been sitting on this review for weeks, because it's been hard for me to suss out my feelings. There were a lot of places where I could appreciate what the author was doing, and yet on the whole I left this book feeling kind of empty.
Probably we could sum up this whole review by saying that I felt like while the book was preaching sex positivity, it was not affirming of people who choose not to have sex. And for me, it's really important that sex positivity be inclusive of people who choose not to have sex, whether that be because they're ace or because they're religious or any other reason that they're choosing not to.
It's important to me that we create space for people to choose not to have sex for religious reasons without making fun of that. Because, if someone were to tell me that my choice as an ace person to not have sex was valid but then they turned around and made fun of someone abstaining for religious reasons, I wouldn't really feel like they thought my choices were valid. And throughout the book, CeCe is pretty disrespectful to the Christian notion of waiting until marriage.
To the author's credit, there's one point in the story where someone asks CeCe if it's okay to not have sex and she says not everyone has to have sex (pg. 126). From that standpoint, yeah, that's on the page. Out loud that's the standpoint CeCe takes, but pretty much everything in her internal monologue makes it seem like she thinks not having sex is silly. Sex is cool, not sex is not cool. There's not necessarily any one particular incident where I get that vibe, it's just the general tone CeCe uses throughout the book that made me feel that way.
Infantilization of people who don't have sex also felt like a common issue, which may relate to why. Throughout the book, CeCe is situated as being the teacher, the person who knows more than everyone because she knows about sex and has had it. At one point, she refers to herself as someone who "lives in the real world" (pg. 139). Her cabinmate calls her out on this and she feels bad and apologizes, but the feeling bad and apologizing go by so quick that they don't feel particularly authentic.
Also, the ending was disappointing. One of the themes of the story was CeCe's sexual insecurity. The way the book ended made it feel like the solution to that wasn't CeCe being comfortable with herself just as she was, but that her insecurities needed to be solved by having good sex with her best friend. The way the story was paced, there was never really any time for CeCe to rise above her insecurities before she has good sex. To me, that made it feel like sex was the solution to her problems and... as an ace person I'm skeptical of portraying sex as a solution to self image issues.
As a final thought, at the end, she strips in the middle of the cafeteria to get sent home. Now, I have a problem with modesty culture and sexualizing girls who choose to show skin. That said, CeCe is prepared to strip down completely in a public space WITH MINORS and she does sexualize the act a little. Which, for all the talk of consent in the book, did everyone in the cafeteria consent to watching a strip show? Her demonstration could easily be off-putting to some people and she doesn't care even a little bit.
Like I said, there are places where it seems like the author is making space for people who don't want to have sex. But they're all sort of like, blink and you miss them. If I weren't reading really closely with the hopes of creating a fair review, I definitely would have missed them and would have felt really gross about the book. Even with the admissions that were made, I just felt a bit off. Other people might feel like what's there covers it, and that's fine. But this is my blog where I get to talk about how the books I read made me feel, and I felt not great about this one.
If something is really about accepting your sexuality, shouldn't you leave feeling comfortable about your sexual choices, whether those choices are to have or not have sex? I didn't get that with this book.
Other thoughts: Overall, I actually found the writing to be pretty engaging. Ironically, it is kind of didactic and preachy. I already mentioned I'm Christian, and I felt that that the book was unfair towards Christians. I don't want to dwell on this because a number of other reviewers have already noted it, but you don't have to agree with Christianity to respect it. CeCe respects her cabinmates, and I loved their friendships, but ultimately she felt very close-minded to me. She invades on another space and makes it all about her. In a lot of ways I appreciated what this book was trying to do, but I think that as a sex-positive Christian, if it had really been balanced, I would have come away feeling empowered rather than defensive. It just missed the mark for me a bit.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Review: Of Curses and Kisses
Summary: A Beauty and the Beast retelling set at a boarding school Rep: Features OwnVoices Indian representation Sexual Content: References ...
-
Summary: In order to win back her ex, CeCe follows him to a summer Bible camp. Representation: One of the minor characters is lesbian....
-
Summary: In this scifi debut, three teens fight government control that outlaws life-saving technology. Representation: Nathaniel, a ma...
-
Summary: A twist of fate forces a witch and a witch-hunter into a marriage to each other. Representation: One of the secondary char...

No comments:
Post a Comment