Thursday, February 27, 2020

Review: One of Us Is Next by Karen McManus

Summary: Three teens get caught up in a deadly game of truth or dare.


Representation: Characters come from various ethnic backgrounds. A gay character from the first book makes several cameo appearances.

Sexual content:  No on-page sex. Lots of discussion of sex as well as some groping and kissing.

Ace Thoughts: From my very first introduction of him, Knox was my favorite character. I love my soft boys, so Knox is a great fit for me with his insecure, theater-geek self. When we meet Knox, it's revealed that he used to date Maeve, one of the other main characters. Maeve reveals that she and Knox broke up because there weren't any physical sparks between them, but they're still friends. That caught my attention because on the one hand, yay for platonic relationships. But on the other hand, the idea that a romantic relationship can't be good if it's not physical is concerning.

At any rate, I was interested to see where this went. (Spoilers ahead). In the course of the truth or dare game, it is announced to the whole school that Maeve broke up with Knox because he "couldn't get it up."

What an absolutely horrifying thought as an ace person. Honestly, the subsequent chapters outlining the abuse Knox receives from his classmates was hard to read. Phoebe, the third POV character comments on how ridiculous it is that she gets shamed for having sex while Knox gets shamed for not having sex. So good on McManus for some discussion on how it shouldn't matter how much sex a person is or isn't having.

The book ends with Knox making out with Phoebe and getting an erection. Which honestly, I could have done without. It sort of makes it seem like him not getting aroused with Maeve was a problem that needed to be fixed.

Writing Thoughts: I liked this book, just as I liked the previous book in the series. It's got some good twists. Character is an area where McManus excels, and I enjoyed meeting a new cast (as well as seeing some familiar faces). I also think the conflict levels are high throughout, which helps make the book really engaging and quick to read.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Review: Of Curses and Kisses

Summary: A Beauty and the Beast retelling set at a boarding school Rep: Features OwnVoices Indian representation Sexual Content: References ...