Summary: Seven students representing seven deadly sins get caught up in a school scandal.
Representation: Book includes an ace/aro character as well as a pansexual character.
Sexual content: Some references to sex as well as on page kissing.
Ace thoughts: Oof. Where to even begin with this. The book includes an ace/aro character, Valentine. And I'll call him ace/aro even though those labels are never used in the book. He pretty explicitly states multiple times that he isn't interested in dating or sex. So the ace/aro coding is really strong. I think it's a mistake that he never explicitly identifies as such. Of course there are plenty of people who go along time not being aware they're a-spec. But Valentine researches everything thoroughly. He demonstrates that he's familiar with pansexuality, and he's very aware that he's not heterosexual. Which makes me think, given everything we know about his character, that he would have researched and been familiar with a-spec identities. Anyway, I'm going to write this review from the standpoint of Valentine being ace/aro.
I actually perused Goodreads reviews of the book before sitting down to write this, and I am absolutely floored that the book isn't getting absolutely shredded for the ace/aro rep. Almost all of the reviews I read were like "Yay! Ace/aro rep!!!" But I tend to prefer no rep to bad rep. The thing about Valentine is that he encapsulates every negative stereotype about a-spec people to ever exist. Every. Single. One. He is cold, has zero social skills, and seems incapable of love (not even with his parents). One of the other characters literally refers to him as the embodiment of awkwardness. Which is all a big yikes.
At one point, another character says something to the effect of not considering him human, which is also a big yikes.
Now, in a book where each main character represents a deadly sin, I'm not expecting fully likable characters. But you could write a flawed a-spec character who didn't fall into every possible stereotype. Valentine represents pride, and could have probably avoided the stereotypes easier with a different sin. Like wrath. Give me an angry ace. That would be so metal. Or even if he was going to be pride, he could be written so that he still has social skills and tact while thinking he's better than other people. There were just so many ways that the stereotypes could have been avoided.
It's also suggested that he's not good looking. He's repeatedly referred to as being scrawny. Which like, maybe isn't a big deal, but I found it kind of annoying. Because again, stereotypes. He could have been hella fine. And not reinforced the idea that someone who doesn't experience sexual attraction isn't sexually attractive to others. Also, aesthetic attraction is a thing.
Here's the kicker. I don't dislike Valentine as a character. Quite the contrary, I find cold, smart boys very endearing. (Is Kaz Brekker one of my all time favorite YA characters? Yes, yes he is) But I hate that someone would read this and associate all these traits with ace/aro people. Maybe if we lived in a world where a-spec people got more rep and had more variation in rep, Valentine's character would be fine. But when there are so few ace/aro characters in YA, it's really problematic. Maybe I'm less bothered that that's the way Valentine is and more bothered that somebody thinks that's the way an ace/aro person would be.
On the bright side, I did think the relationship between Valentine and Lucas was precious, and I liked that Lucas was cool about still wanting to be friends after Valentine turns him down.
As a final note on Valentine, I don't believe it's explicitly stated, but it is suggested that he is autistic as well. I'm not qualified to speak on that area of representation, but would be very interested to hear what an autistic person had to say about it.
Writing thoughts: While I thought the characters were interesting, the book overall felt a little lackluster to me. For one thing, I didn't really buy into the way the school went about investigating the student/teacher scandal. For another, the stakes just seemed really low. Like what was the book building towards? I also wished the characters interacted more. There's like one scene where they're mostly all in the same place, and I would have liked more of that. So the writing was okay for me, but not great.
Monday, December 23, 2019
Thursday, December 12, 2019
Review: The Merciful Crow by Margaret Owen
Summary: In order to protect her caste, Fie must escort a prince to safety.
Representation: Prince Jasimir is gay. His bodyguard Tavin is bi or pan (neither word is actually used in the book, but he says that "gender never mattered" to him).
Sexual Content: There is a sex scene that I would describe as medium level graphic for YA. Also a fair bit of kissing and a number of references to sex.
Ace Thoughts: This isn't a book I would describe as ace-mismic, but rather one I would describe as reinforcing allo-normativity. Early on in Fie's interactions with Tavin she makes an off-hand remark about how many lovers he's had. I don't believe that he had mentioned anything about his romantic or sexual life before, so Fie has basically assumed that a handsome and charismatic young man must have a long list of people he's slept with. As an ace person, it's frustrating to see people assuming that anyone has had sex. In some ways, it's even more off-putting that the assumption is driven by the fact that he's charming/attractive/etc. because it almost suggests that if a person is not having sex, it's because they are not those things.
Throughout the book there were a number of off-hand comments like that, which really established allo-normativity. I don't think that's anything malicious on the author's part, but just a reflection of the real world. Still, as I've started this blog, one of the things I've started doing is asking myself "how would it feel to be an asexual or aromantic person in this world?" In this case, I'd have to say that there were a number of things said by characters in the book that could make my hypothetical ace or aro person feel uncomfortable. Which again, is really just a reflection of the real world.
There was one part that I found a little bothersome (some spoilers ahead). At one point Jesimir makes a comment about the fact that Fie and Tavin have had sex and it appears that he is a bit grossed out or at the very least doesn't want to think about it. Fie responds my mocking him. She is not sympathetic to him feeling uncomfortable. Worse, she goes on to make a comment about how he's old enough to have figured out what sex is, or something to that effect (normally I'd include a quote here, but this was an audiobook listen for me so it's hard to go back and find things). The way the comment was delivered, I think it could be interpreted as people who are bothered by sex or inexperienced in it are childish or immature. Infantilization is a huge issue for ace people, and this moment really stirred that up for me.
Writing Thoughts: I have friends who love this book. I liked it okay. Maybe part of my lack of enthusiasm was that I wasn't sold on the audiobook narrator. The world was interesting enough. The plot felt a little like it kept repeating elements of conflict the characters had already resolved. Honestly, Jesimir was the only character who I was deeply interested in. The others were mildly interesting but felt like characters I'd already read in other books. Overall for me it was something I'm glad I read but not necessarily a sequel that I'm going to snatch up the minute it comes out.
Would I recommend this book to ace/aro readers? Maybe. Like I said, there's definitely some allo-normativity, but your reading list might be pretty short if you ruled out every YA with that.
Tuesday, December 10, 2019
Review: Comics Will Break Your Heart by Faith Erin Hicks
Summary: Years after an intellectual rights settlement nearly destroyed their families, two teens meet and fall for each other.
Sexual Content: No sex. Some light kissing.
Sexual Content: No sex. Some light kissing.
Ace Thoughts: There are no openly ace/aro characters. There is one brief mention of Mir, one of the main characters having a "platonic girl crush" on Natalie Portman. So there's a little squish shout out.
One thing I liked was that while Mir's love interest is Weldon, she has a best friend who gracefully accepts her rejection of his feelings for her. He makes it clear that he's interested, and she politely turns him down. And he's totally cool with it. Doesn't make things awkward. Doesn't do any sad boy pining. He's just like, yeah, we're still bffs. This isn't strictly an ace issue. People should just be graceful when their feelings aren't reciprocated. But as an ace person, seeing a relationship depicted where the character values their bond with the other person enough to be as invested in a friendship with them as a romance--well that's pretty cool. I'm all for anything that elevates the value of friendships.
The book also has some good thoughts on how a friendship can change when one of the friends enters a romantic relationship. It's resolved in a sort of bitter-sweet way that said the friendship had been changed permanently but still had some good in it. It felt realistic to me. Again, this isn't an issue that relates only to ace/aro people, but can be particularly poignant to our communities as we may be less likely than our friends to pursue or enter relationships, leaving us the odd one out when our friends begin relationships.
One thing I liked was that while Mir's love interest is Weldon, she has a best friend who gracefully accepts her rejection of his feelings for her. He makes it clear that he's interested, and she politely turns him down. And he's totally cool with it. Doesn't make things awkward. Doesn't do any sad boy pining. He's just like, yeah, we're still bffs. This isn't strictly an ace issue. People should just be graceful when their feelings aren't reciprocated. But as an ace person, seeing a relationship depicted where the character values their bond with the other person enough to be as invested in a friendship with them as a romance--well that's pretty cool. I'm all for anything that elevates the value of friendships.
The book also has some good thoughts on how a friendship can change when one of the friends enters a romantic relationship. It's resolved in a sort of bitter-sweet way that said the friendship had been changed permanently but still had some good in it. It felt realistic to me. Again, this isn't an issue that relates only to ace/aro people, but can be particularly poignant to our communities as we may be less likely than our friends to pursue or enter relationships, leaving us the odd one out when our friends begin relationships.
Writing Thoughts: The story was a decent, quick read. The main characters felt a little bland to me, which is not what I want when I read a cutesy romance. There were a lot of themes and points of conflict running through the book, which helped keep me engaged even though I wasn't exactly swooning over the characters. I'm not going to be fangirling over this one, but it was worth the read for me.
Would I recommend to ace/aro readers: Yes. There is romance, but there's a lot of other story threads happening too.
Sunday, December 1, 2019
Review: Crown of Coral and Pearl by Mara Rutherford
Summary: When her twin sister is gravely injured, Nor must go in her place to become the bride-to-be of a cruel prince.
Sexual Content: No sex. A couple kissing scenes and a couple light references to sex.
Ace Thoughts: There are no openly ace/aro characters (though there was a very minor character named Aro) in the story, but I thought there were some very ace/aro-friendly sentiments. As an ace person, I always love books that explore deep, loving relationships that aren't sexual or romantic. There is a romance in this book, but the relationship between Nor and her sister, Zadie takes center stage. Throughout the book, it's made clear that their relationship is just as important as the romantic relationships in the book. Zadie tells Nor, "He may have my heart, but you, my dear, beautiful Nor, are the twin of my soul" (pg. 134). There are similar reflections throughout the book.
Interestingly, there's one brief moment where Zadie displays a little hurt over the fact that Zadie has found a romantic relationship. I would have actually liked to see more because the effect that a romantic relationship can have on a person's platonic relationships is something that I think is of interested to the ace/aro community.
I actually could see Nor as possibly being coded as grey-aro. She and Zadie have a conversation about boys in their village and from that I get the sense that Zadie has never noticed or cared about any of them. She is romantically attracted to someone later in the book. Like I said, there's no explicit mention of her being on the aro spectrum, but I think there's room to read her that way. Either way, she's a good example of a character who primarily prioritizes other relationships and things over romance.
Writing Thoughts: I could just gush about this book forever. The world is so unique and established so smoothly. The characters are so fleshed out, and the antagonist in particular is one of the most interesting and compelling I've seen in a long time. Pacing on point. I just loved reading this. Stayed up way past my bedtime to finish!
Would I recommend to ace/aro readers: I think this could be a really good option for ace/aro readers. Although there's no explicit ace/aro representation, the book is relatively little sexual content. While there is romance, there's also a strong emphasis on the importance of familial bonds, that I think is appealing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Review: Of Curses and Kisses
Summary: A Beauty and the Beast retelling set at a boarding school Rep: Features OwnVoices Indian representation Sexual Content: References ...
-
Summary: In order to win back her ex, CeCe follows him to a summer Bible camp. Representation: One of the minor characters is lesbian....
-
Summary: In this scifi debut, three teens fight government control that outlaws life-saving technology. Representation: Nathaniel, a ma...
-
Summary: A twist of fate forces a witch and a witch-hunter into a marriage to each other. Representation: One of the secondary char...



