Representation:
Winnie is a fat, black girl in a committed queer platonic relationship.
Sexual Content:
No sex, some kissing.
Ace Thoughts:
This is the first book I've read with a queer platonic relationship. Winnie and Kara are ungirlfriends, which is a fun term and fitting for their relationship. Unfortunately, the relationship between Winnie and Kara seemed kind of unhealthy. Without going into too many spoilers, Kara does something that really crosses a line. It's acknowledged that her actions were wrong, but then it's just sort of brushed over. I never quite got over what she did, and it sort of soured me on Kara's character and her relationship with Winnie for the rest of the book. Which was so unfortunate, because like I said, I've never seen a QPR portrayed in a book. I just wish it was one that felt healthier to me. I did like that the book examined the difficulty of maintaining a QPR as she's also wanting to enter a romantic relationship for the first time.
No sex, some kissing.
Ace Thoughts:
This is the first book I've read with a queer platonic relationship. Winnie and Kara are ungirlfriends, which is a fun term and fitting for their relationship. Unfortunately, the relationship between Winnie and Kara seemed kind of unhealthy. Without going into too many spoilers, Kara does something that really crosses a line. It's acknowledged that her actions were wrong, but then it's just sort of brushed over. I never quite got over what she did, and it sort of soured me on Kara's character and her relationship with Winnie for the rest of the book. Which was so unfortunate, because like I said, I've never seen a QPR portrayed in a book. I just wish it was one that felt healthier to me. I did like that the book examined the difficulty of maintaining a QPR as she's also wanting to enter a romantic relationship for the first time.
Writing Thoughts:
The rep in this book is so important and fantastic, and perfectly summarized in that gorgeous cover. For me, the book is at it's best when it's taking on issues like fat-shaming. Unfortunately, I felt like the plot took a backseat to the issues the book was trying to tackle. Don't get me wrong, I love issues books and read a lot of them. But even when tackling issues, the book needs to have a steady source of plot. This book as a whole felt really disjointed and meandering to me. It was kind of like I finished it and then couldn't even really tell you what the plot was. There's some sources of conflict, but often the book felt pretty directionless. It sounds like the book is trying to be enemies to lovers, but that didn't come through for me at all. I also felt like the issue with Kara mentioned above was the result of the author trying to add in some plot. So not my favorite writing, but I considered it worth the read anyway for the rep.
Would I recommend this book to ace/aro readers?
Probably. Like I said, I didn't love the writing, but there were some really relatable moments in there for me as well.
The rep in this book is so important and fantastic, and perfectly summarized in that gorgeous cover. For me, the book is at it's best when it's taking on issues like fat-shaming. Unfortunately, I felt like the plot took a backseat to the issues the book was trying to tackle. Don't get me wrong, I love issues books and read a lot of them. But even when tackling issues, the book needs to have a steady source of plot. This book as a whole felt really disjointed and meandering to me. It was kind of like I finished it and then couldn't even really tell you what the plot was. There's some sources of conflict, but often the book felt pretty directionless. It sounds like the book is trying to be enemies to lovers, but that didn't come through for me at all. I also felt like the issue with Kara mentioned above was the result of the author trying to add in some plot. So not my favorite writing, but I considered it worth the read anyway for the rep.
Would I recommend this book to ace/aro readers?
Probably. Like I said, I didn't love the writing, but there were some really relatable moments in there for me as well.





Comme