Sunday, August 2, 2020

Review: Of Curses and Kisses

Summary: A Beauty and the Beast retelling set at a boarding school



Rep: Features OwnVoices Indian representation

Sexual Content: References to sex, but none on page. Kissing.

Ace Thoughts: As the book is based off Beauty and the Beast, it's not surprising that Grey is anti-social. There are also several times in the beginning where he's sort of unintentionally coded as ace or aro. In particular there's one scene where Jaya and Grey are talking and Grey says he doesn't date. There's really no context or reason given. He just says he doesn't date. Jaya immediately starts wondering what trauma could have possibly caused him not to date. He's so dark and mysterious, there must be a reason! It must be something terrible. He could... just not be interested in dating. The thought never crosses her mind. Is the book overly harmful? Probably not. But that scene felt exceptionally like ace/aro erasure.

Writing Thoughts:  Honestly, as a long time fan of Menon's books, I was a little disappointed in this one. The character motivations were there. It was atmospheric. I just don't know that I ever got to a point where I could see why Grey and Jaya were a good fit for each other romantically. They never really clicked to me. And since it's a romance first and foremost, not having a really shipable couple pretty well sunk (pun absolutely intended) the book for me. Definitely try her Dimpleverse books, though. They're cute!

Friday, May 8, 2020

Review: If These Wings Could Fly by Kyrie McCauley

Summary: A mysterious crow invasion centers on the home suffering from domestic abuse.


Rep: Features a biracial love interest.

Sexual Content: A decent amount of kissing. References to sex, but no on-page sex.

Ace Thoughts: This book contains a scene where the main character considers having sex with her boyfriend and decides not to. She decides that it would be fine if she did, but that she just doesn't want to yet, and that's treated as a fine and okay decision. As an ace reader, I'm always here for validating the choice to not have sex. We spend a lot of time in YA defending the right to have sex, that it's rare to see a book where it's clear that the choice to not have sex is valid, and that it's valid regardless of the reason the character chooses not to have sex.

Another thing that stood out to me is that Leighton, the main character, has been nicknamed Ice Queen by a boy she rejected romantically. This raises my ace hackles because it demonstrates the link people (erroneously) make between lack of romantic/sexual feelings and lack of any feelings. It feeds into the perception that people who don't participate in romance/sex are cold. To be clear, this implication is not condoned in anyway in the book. The book clearly treats this nickname as a bad thing. I mention it though because as an ace reader, it certainly stuck out to me.

Writing Thoughts: This book was absolutely beautiful. The tone was engaging and it deals with the subject of abuse in a realistic but optimistic way. The magical realism elements lend the perfect tone to it. I read this book through very quickly. Almost in one sitting, just because it flowed so well. The love interest is charming and all of the characters felt fleshed out and real. This is definitely one I'll be recommending to others.

Review: Belle Révolte by Linsey Miller

Summary: Two girls agree to switch places so that each can pursue learning the type of magic she wishes.


Rep: Lots of great rep in this one! Most of the cast is queer, including our biromantic ace heroine, Annette.

Sexual Content: Kissing.

Ace Thoughts: As far as I could tell, the rep in this one was good. Annette is comfortable with who she is, and it's refreshing to read a book where there's not strong themes of ace trauma. Those books are good and important too, I read as many of them as I can. But sometimes the escapism of having a character who gets to be ace and meet little resistance for it is just really nice. Sometimes it's really nice to read an ace who mostly doesn't have to deal with the worst parts of being ace.

There is one point where Annette mentions a boy she had dated who had made her feel like love without sex was impossible. So she's not completely free of ace trauma, but for the most part, she's very confident with herself. This is one of the few ace characters I've read where I didn't feel like their aceness was constantly being centered. She just got to be. And that was kinda cool.

Writing Thoughts: I wish I could say I love this book. The rep was so good across the board. I loved the author's last book. This one just fell flat, though. In one of those ways where it's hard to even identify where it went wrong. I was just so bored that I found myself skimming long sections. I think one of the issues is that there were way too many characters and I could never keep them straight. The world is really cool, and I like the idea of fighting against a heavily gendered magic system. I just couldn't get into it, unfortunately.

Monday, April 13, 2020

Review: Have a Little Faith in Me by Sonia Hartl

Summary: In order to win back her ex, CeCe follows him to a summer Bible camp.



Representation: One of the minor characters is lesbian.

Sexual Content: Probably easiest to just say...lots. It's central to the book's theme of sex positivity and consent. They talk about it a lot and there is one detailed sex scene.

Ace thoughts: I knew this book might be a bit of mine field going into it. I am both ace and deeply Christian. The book had excellent reviews, so I figured maybe the subjects were handled well and I'd give it a try. Honestly, I've been sitting on this review for weeks, because it's been hard for me to suss out my feelings. There were a lot of places where I could appreciate what the author was doing, and yet on the whole I left this book feeling kind of empty.

Probably we could sum up this whole review by saying that I felt like while the book was preaching sex positivity, it was not affirming of people who choose not to have sex. And for me, it's really important that sex positivity be inclusive of people who choose not to have sex, whether that be because they're ace or because they're religious or any other reason that they're choosing not to.

It's important to me that we create space for people to choose not to have sex for religious reasons without making fun of that. Because, if someone were to tell me that my choice as an ace person to not have sex was valid but then they turned around and made fun of someone abstaining for religious reasons, I wouldn't really feel like they thought my choices were valid. And throughout the book, CeCe is pretty disrespectful to the Christian notion of waiting until marriage.

To the author's credit, there's one point in the story where someone asks CeCe if it's okay to not have sex and she says not everyone has to have sex (pg. 126). From that standpoint, yeah, that's on the page. Out loud that's the standpoint CeCe takes, but pretty much everything in her internal monologue makes it seem like she thinks not having sex is silly. Sex is cool, not sex is not cool. There's not necessarily any one particular incident where I get that vibe, it's just the general tone CeCe uses throughout the book that made me feel that way.

Infantilization of people who don't have sex also felt like a common issue, which may relate to why. Throughout the book, CeCe is situated as being the teacher, the person who knows more than everyone because she knows about sex and has had it. At one point, she refers to herself as someone who "lives in the real world" (pg. 139). Her cabinmate calls her out on this and she feels bad and apologizes, but the feeling bad and apologizing go by so quick that they don't feel particularly authentic.

Also, the ending was disappointing. One of the themes of the story was CeCe's sexual insecurity. The way the book ended made it feel like the solution to that wasn't CeCe being comfortable with herself just as she was, but that her insecurities needed to be solved by having good sex with her best friend. The way the story was paced, there was never really any time for CeCe to rise above her insecurities before she has good sex. To me, that made it feel like sex was the solution to her problems and... as an ace person I'm skeptical of portraying sex as a solution to self image issues.

As a final thought, at the end, she strips in the middle of the cafeteria to get sent home. Now, I have a problem with modesty culture and sexualizing girls who choose to show skin. That said, CeCe is prepared to strip down completely in a public space WITH MINORS and she does sexualize the act a little. Which, for all the talk of consent in the book, did everyone in the cafeteria consent to watching a strip show? Her demonstration could easily be off-putting to some people and she doesn't care even a little bit.

Like I said, there are places where it seems like the author is making space for people who don't want to have sex. But they're all sort of like, blink and you miss them. If I weren't reading really closely  with the hopes of creating a fair review, I definitely would have missed them and would have felt really gross about the book. Even with the admissions that were made, I just felt a bit off. Other people might feel like what's there covers it, and that's fine. But this is my blog where I get to talk about how the books I read made me feel, and I felt not great about this one.

If something is really about accepting your sexuality, shouldn't you leave feeling comfortable about your sexual choices, whether those choices are to have or not have sex? I didn't get that with this book.

Other thoughts: Overall, I actually found the writing to be pretty engaging. Ironically, it is kind of didactic and preachy. I already mentioned I'm Christian, and I felt that that the book was unfair towards Christians. I don't want to dwell on this because a number of other reviewers have already noted it, but you don't have to agree with Christianity to respect it. CeCe respects her cabinmates, and I loved their friendships, but ultimately she felt very close-minded to me. She invades on another space and makes it all about her. In a lot of ways I appreciated what this book was trying to do, but I think that as a sex-positive Christian, if it had really been balanced, I would have come away feeling empowered rather than defensive. It just missed the mark for me a bit.

Thursday, February 27, 2020

Review: One of Us Is Next by Karen McManus

Summary: Three teens get caught up in a deadly game of truth or dare.


Representation: Characters come from various ethnic backgrounds. A gay character from the first book makes several cameo appearances.

Sexual content:  No on-page sex. Lots of discussion of sex as well as some groping and kissing.

Ace Thoughts: From my very first introduction of him, Knox was my favorite character. I love my soft boys, so Knox is a great fit for me with his insecure, theater-geek self. When we meet Knox, it's revealed that he used to date Maeve, one of the other main characters. Maeve reveals that she and Knox broke up because there weren't any physical sparks between them, but they're still friends. That caught my attention because on the one hand, yay for platonic relationships. But on the other hand, the idea that a romantic relationship can't be good if it's not physical is concerning.

At any rate, I was interested to see where this went. (Spoilers ahead). In the course of the truth or dare game, it is announced to the whole school that Maeve broke up with Knox because he "couldn't get it up."

What an absolutely horrifying thought as an ace person. Honestly, the subsequent chapters outlining the abuse Knox receives from his classmates was hard to read. Phoebe, the third POV character comments on how ridiculous it is that she gets shamed for having sex while Knox gets shamed for not having sex. So good on McManus for some discussion on how it shouldn't matter how much sex a person is or isn't having.

The book ends with Knox making out with Phoebe and getting an erection. Which honestly, I could have done without. It sort of makes it seem like him not getting aroused with Maeve was a problem that needed to be fixed.

Writing Thoughts: I liked this book, just as I liked the previous book in the series. It's got some good twists. Character is an area where McManus excels, and I enjoyed meeting a new cast (as well as seeing some familiar faces). I also think the conflict levels are high throughout, which helps make the book really engaging and quick to read.

Saturday, February 22, 2020

Review: Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe by Alire Sáenz

Summer: Misfit Aristotle's friendship with Dante evolves as he navigates personal struggles.


Representation: Aristotle and Dante are both Mexican American teens, and their identities as such are central to the story. MLM romance.

Sexual Content: There is kissing. No sex, though there are references to it at various points.

Ace thoughts: Throughout the book, Aristotle shows some signs of discomfort with dating and romance. At one point he questions why a boy couldn't just be friends with girls.

He expresses how his inability to form sexual/romantic attachments with girls makes him feel like an outsider. One part in particular stood out to me:

"I pictured Dante kissing her, telling her that everything was all right. Dante who loved kissing dogs, who loved kissing his parents, who loved kissing boys, who even loved kissing girls. Maybe kissing was part of the human condition. Maybe I wasn't human. Maybe I wasn't part of the natural order of things... I thought masturbating was embarassing. I didn't even know why. It just was. It was like having sex with yourself. Having sex with yourself was really weird... God, I felt stupid just thinking about these things. Some guys talked about sex all the time. I heard them at school Why were they so happy when they talked about sex? It made me feel miserable. Inadequate." (not sure what page this is, since I had an ebook copy on Overdrive)

I don't think its hard to see some sentiment in there that an ace person would connect with. I think sort of the assumption when you read the book is that Aristotle feels this way about sex because he's repressing the fact that he likes boys (specifically, Dante). Which resonates with a lot of gay people, I'm sure, who identify as a-spec before determining that they're actually gay. And that's totally valid! Some people identify as ace they're ace only to reassess that label later and embrace a different sexuality. Which is totally okay because a) sexuality is fluid and b) finding the right label can be hard.

I also like to think there's room to interpret Aristotle as a-spec though, since being gay and being a-spec aren't mutually exclusive. At any rate, I think this highlights the need to de-stigmatize aversions towards sex, which are harmful to people both on and off the a-spec.

Writing Thoughts: This is a big YA title, and I'm surprised it's taken me this long to get to it. Overall, I liked it. I didn't necessarily connect with the voice all the time, but it's very heartfelt. I enjoyed watching Aristotle's realtionships with other characters evolve over the course of the book. A great coming of age tale.

Saturday, February 1, 2020

Review: Our Wayward Fate by Gloria Chao

Summary: As the only Asian in her school, Ali struggles to fit in, only to have her world turned upside down when Chase Yu, another Taiwanese teen moves to town.


Representation: The story features Taiwanese American teens as well as a gay side character.

Sexual Content: Quite a bit of kissing, so references to sex but no on-page sex.

Ace Thoughts: I initially struggled with the romance a little because it seems very insta-lovey. Which isn't inherently bad, but doesn't really connect with my demiromantic tendencies.  Like I get that some people experience attraction that way, but I just don't.

What I did love from an ace perspective though is the way sex was handled. Ali and Chase aren't in any way coded as ace. There is one part where they are in a hotel room alone together. The possibility of them having sex is brought up. And they just choose not to. And the whole point is that they could but they aren't, and that's okay. Now, the book would have been totally fine if they had had sex. It would be perfectly normal. But it's also perfectly normal and okay for two people, whether they're ace or not, to just not have sex. I love that this book normalizes that a bit.

Also, the book is good in terms of exploring non-romantic relationships. In particular, the family relationships are really well done.

Writing Thoughts: Other than not being totally sold on the romance (which again, is more personal taste than an actual critique about the book), I really loved this one. I particularly loved the way the connections between family members were portrayed. The voice was really natural, and it made for a nice, easy read.

Friday, January 10, 2020

Review: Hot Dog Girl by Jennifer Dugan

Summary: Lou's schemes to create the best summer possible land her in trouble.


Representation: A bi protagonist with a lesbian love interest.

Sexual content: Kissing. A handful of references of sex.

Ace thoughts: Throughout the book, Lou is scheming to get with this guy she likes, which involves fake dating her best friend, Seely. There are lots of points where Lou thinking about how pretty Seely is or how she likes touching her. Ultimately, this comes down to Lou being oblivious of the fact that she has romantic feelings for her best friend. It's interesting to examine from the standpoint of a split attraction model though. Because before Lou realizes her feelings for Seely aren't platonic, there's this really beautiful space where she's aware that she's experiencing aesthetic and sensual attraction. So for awhile there's this feeling that you can experience those types of attraction separate from romantic or sexual attraction.

Sure, in Lou's case those feelings are connected to romantic feelings that she hasn't recognized yet. But I think the book creates space for certain types of attraction to exist without being connected to other types of attraction. Or at least, I'd like to thinks so.

Writing thoughts: Fake dating is one of my favorite tropes, and this book did not disappoint in execution. Lou's voice is engaging and she's flawed in very relatable ways. Overall, a cute story that I absolutely flew through.

Review: Of Curses and Kisses

Summary: A Beauty and the Beast retelling set at a boarding school Rep: Features OwnVoices Indian representation Sexual Content: References ...