Representation: Prince Jasimir is gay. His bodyguard Tavin is bi or pan (neither word is actually used in the book, but he says that "gender never mattered" to him).
Sexual Content: There is a sex scene that I would describe as medium level graphic for YA. Also a fair bit of kissing and a number of references to sex.
Ace Thoughts: This isn't a book I would describe as ace-mismic, but rather one I would describe as reinforcing allo-normativity. Early on in Fie's interactions with Tavin she makes an off-hand remark about how many lovers he's had. I don't believe that he had mentioned anything about his romantic or sexual life before, so Fie has basically assumed that a handsome and charismatic young man must have a long list of people he's slept with. As an ace person, it's frustrating to see people assuming that anyone has had sex. In some ways, it's even more off-putting that the assumption is driven by the fact that he's charming/attractive/etc. because it almost suggests that if a person is not having sex, it's because they are not those things.
Throughout the book there were a number of off-hand comments like that, which really established allo-normativity. I don't think that's anything malicious on the author's part, but just a reflection of the real world. Still, as I've started this blog, one of the things I've started doing is asking myself "how would it feel to be an asexual or aromantic person in this world?" In this case, I'd have to say that there were a number of things said by characters in the book that could make my hypothetical ace or aro person feel uncomfortable. Which again, is really just a reflection of the real world.
There was one part that I found a little bothersome (some spoilers ahead). At one point Jesimir makes a comment about the fact that Fie and Tavin have had sex and it appears that he is a bit grossed out or at the very least doesn't want to think about it. Fie responds my mocking him. She is not sympathetic to him feeling uncomfortable. Worse, she goes on to make a comment about how he's old enough to have figured out what sex is, or something to that effect (normally I'd include a quote here, but this was an audiobook listen for me so it's hard to go back and find things). The way the comment was delivered, I think it could be interpreted as people who are bothered by sex or inexperienced in it are childish or immature. Infantilization is a huge issue for ace people, and this moment really stirred that up for me.
Writing Thoughts: I have friends who love this book. I liked it okay. Maybe part of my lack of enthusiasm was that I wasn't sold on the audiobook narrator. The world was interesting enough. The plot felt a little like it kept repeating elements of conflict the characters had already resolved. Honestly, Jesimir was the only character who I was deeply interested in. The others were mildly interesting but felt like characters I'd already read in other books. Overall for me it was something I'm glad I read but not necessarily a sequel that I'm going to snatch up the minute it comes out.
Would I recommend this book to ace/aro readers? Maybe. Like I said, there's definitely some allo-normativity, but your reading list might be pretty short if you ruled out every YA with that.

No comments:
Post a Comment